These two label categories are only the core of what is asked of a person, “How do you identify?” Each label implies certain criteria and expectations of the person claiming said label. However, more often than not, the label doesn’t “technically” fit the labeler. It is my experience that each person molds themselves to fit their chosen label, or vice versa. In some cases, the label is chosen by default… a process of elimination.
I was never asked to label myself until a few months ago. I was approached at a bar and asked “How do you identify?” My response was immediate: A lesbian.
Sure. It fits. Kind of.
What does it mean to be a lesbian? In simple terms: a person who identifies as female who is attracted to others who identify as female.
The problem being: I don’t necessarily identify as the societally accepted “girl.” I don’t feel male, either. So, what does that make me?
This thought process brought me to question what my identity truly was, if I needed to label it at all, and if others were having the same issues identifying themselves.
So, in order to aid in my process, I posed a request to a diverse group of people and gathered their responses below:
“Write a statement, honestly and thoroughly, along the lines of ‘I identify as (…) and what that means to me is (…)’ in regard to sexuality and gender identity.”
A.L.N.
I identify as a person who is constantly changing but I guess most of the time I just identify as a queer trans man, although I enjoy confusing people immensely. I’ve never really felt ‘female’ and I don’t feel ‘male’. To me that means that I’m able to just be myself. I don’t feel the need to hide my feminine side or my masculine side for anyone. I am attracted to people who were born with “female” as their assigned gender.
H.L.
I identify as a "straight" man. To me, that means that I am physically, and equally important, emotionally, attracted to females. Other than that, it bears no weight whatsoever in my life. I don't think my interests, hobbies, the way I dress or, specially, who I am friends with, should in any way have anything to do with my sexuality.
J.L.A.
I identify as Jessica, a 23 year old lesbian who is on the brink of having a mid-life crisis. To me, that means that I am solely comfortable with sexuality and being gay, but sometimes other shit just gets in the way, somehow. My sexuality is only a portion of what I really am. I identify as ME.
E.R.A.
I am a queer, multi-dimensional , person of color who has been “out of the closet” since the age of 5.
I am fierce and frightening depending on one’s perception and personal experience.
My gender is fluid, allowing me to ebb and flow through the dominant paradigm. By not having to adhere to patriarchal gender roles, I incite anger in some while titillating others. I identify as a monogamous yet flirtatious, queer, submissive, kinky switch.
Notice how none of these responses are a line or less? Identity means more than labels. It’s a combination of how a person looks at themself and how they are perceived by others. I’m still working on mine, but let me pose the question to you…
How do you identify?
Me.
ReplyDeleteSeriously, my first response to that question was that I'm me, plain and simple. Yes, I'm a lot of things that would probably get interesting labels; mother, bitch, straight, insane, masculine (as opposed to girly), etc. Not one of those are things I identify with comfortably. Does that make any sense? It does to me. ;)
Makes perfect sense.
ReplyDeleteWhen the aliens invade, we'll all be made to look exactly the same, anyway, so what's the point? ;)
Identity, hetero-male with a hint of be careful. I am a fairly open book to those that know me...I judge no-one and will not be judged. I have lived I fear much longer than most of your readers, age doesn't always bring wisdom but it has allowed me to witness firsthand the blossoming of the gender identity personifications thru the years and the way people react to them....I feel blessed I guess cause for me its so simple
ReplyDelete"A hint of careful."
ReplyDeleteI'm stealing that line. :)
I think it would be more simple if everyone didn't feel the need to label. If we could all answer "me" like Renee and J.L.A. in my post, then there wouldn't be a question of identity.
But "Me" isn't good enough. We all have to be classified, categoried, and counted. Thank you, census for the mind fuck.
I am me; All the other things that I do, am interested or involved in, represent one side or view or interpretation of who or what I am.
ReplyDelete...and No, I don't fit in a damn box you can check off like items on a grocery list.
I hate labels, I hate boxes, and No... I will not keep my colours inside the lines.
Damn census bastards and their mind-fucking nonsense. Let's start a petition.
ReplyDeleteWhat? Really? Never mind, there's too much walking and begging involved in petitions. Let's just be loud and obnoxious and hope someone is listening.
Besides, my petition is Canadian, so it wouldn't count.
BTW, my captcha for this comment was dinco.
I can honestly say it is entirely in my nature to label everything. I categorize, decipher, and tuck away every little thing I have and know into neat boxes. I gladly allow anyone to be who or what they want to be,knowing full well my personal effect on 99.99999% of the world is, well..nonexistent..and what I think only means something to me, but I will always watch and make decisions. I know how people tend to label me, and no, I don't like what they come up with. But I will never stop the labeling. Whether I disagree or not. I identify as a labeler.
ReplyDeleteThis is a very difficult question for me to answer. Shortest version: I identify as me. Longer: I'm attracted to personality, not gender. I've had a relationship with a woman, but at that time I really couldn't have cared less that she was "female", I loved her personality. I've has a relationship with a very androgynous and gender-confused person, but what I saw and loved was their personality. Now I'm married to a quite masculine guy, but I don't care that he's "a man", I love him as the person he is. So what does this label me as? I couldn't say bisexual and couldn't say straight either. I'm me, and very comfortable in my own skin.
ReplyDeleteI just can't think in terms of labels, they don't matter as much as an ant's fart to me. :)